The 2027 Forester Wilderness Hybrid costs $42,020, including a $1,525 destination fee. That's $1,000 more than the gas Wilderness. Subaru offers no factory options beyond the floor mats and paint, and our Geyser Blue tester cost nothing extra.
The EPA rates the Wilderness Hybrid at 33 mpg city, 29 highway, and 31 combined, compared with 24, 28, and 26 for the gas Wilderness. At 15,000 miles a year and $4 per gallon, the hybrid saves about $370 a year in fuel, so it pays back its premium in under three years. Its 16.6-gallon tank gives it over 500 miles of range. Off-road is another story. We saw mileage in the low teens on the trail.
The problem is the competition. The only other off-road-themed hybrids in this class are the Toyota RAV4 Woodland and the Honda CR-V TrailSport, and both cost less and use less fuel. The RAV4 Woodland starts at $41,495 and is rated at 38 mpg combined. The CR-V TrailSport starts at $40,750 and is rated at 35 mpg combined. Using the same math, the RAV4 would save about $350 a year in fuel over the Subaru, and the CR-V about $220. Neither is nearly as capable as the Forester Wilderness Hybrid in serious off-road conditions, but for owners planning to spend far more time on pavement than on dirt, they're the better choices.
It's also worth noting that the Wilderness Hybrid trails its own siblings in fuel economy, and those siblings are no slouches off-road in their own right. Other Forester Hybrid trims are rated as high as 36 mpg combined, and the Premium Hybrid starts at $36,255.
Some shoppers may be lured by the Outback Wilderness and its 260-hp turbocharged engine, but it costs $45,540 and is rated at just 23 mpg combined.
Subaru's warranty is typical for the class, at three years or 36,000 miles bumper to bumper and five years or 60,000 miles on the powertrain. The hybrid components are covered for eight years or 100,000 miles.
The Wilderness Hybrid makes the most sense for buyers who will actually use its capability. Think of someone who lives in a city in a snowy climate and spends weekends skiing, camping, or hiking. For that driver, the small footprint and better mileage pay off on weekdays, and the hardware pays off on weekends. Shoppers who rarely leave the pavement will spend less to buy and run a Toyota RAV4 or Honda CR-V.